Slant with Demetra
-
- Posts: 48
- Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2018 9:01 pm
Slant with Demetra
I recently decided to change the slit from 25μ to 35μ. I found that the calibration lines are slanted, as well as the emision lines of background sky in long exposures.
If i am not wrong, this is due to the slit a bit turned.
When procesing the images with Demetra, in the step "geometry", correction is possible in tilt and smile, but i found difficult to correct for slant.
Trying the button "calculate", Demetra does a poor job as the slant is increased! I tried to chnge the numbers manually but it seems difficult.
Am i doing something wrong?
Thanks for advice.
David Cejudo.
Observatorio El gallinero.
El berrueco (Spain)
David Cejudo.
Observatorio El gallinero.
El berrueco, Madrid.
Observatorio El gallinero.
El berrueco, Madrid.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 10:42 am
Re: Slant with Demetra
Hello
Did you selected an area around a line before trying to detect the smile value ?
Nicolas
Did you selected an area around a line before trying to detect the smile value ?
Nicolas
-
- Posts: 1041
- Joined: Mon Aug 31, 2015 11:26 am
Re: Slant with Demetra
Just a question, with slit 35µm what is your resolution ?
-
- Posts: 48
- Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2018 9:01 pm
Re: Slant with Demetra
Hello, all.
Yes, i selected an area around a line while trying smile correction. But smile just fixes the curvature of the line, not its slant. I recently knew that Demetra does not correcft for slant. I suppose slant is already taken care of by fixing the slit correctly with the screws, mechanically, and following the procedure stated in the manual. I guess this is the best means, but whenever the slit is changed, the procedure must be done again as the square mirror (the slit) emplacement has some play, it does not sit snuggly. It does not fit exactly in its location. You may try either moving just very slightly the mirror with a small pick until no slant is observed or -better- dismount the spectroscope from the telescope and use those screws to fix it. The manual states that the guider should be used for this correction. I wonder -i did not try it yet- if could it be a good idea to use the calibrating lamp an its spectral lines -using the main camera- to perform this correction by checking the lines verticallity. Also with this procedure it is easy to check if at the acquisition camera's chip the spectrum is horizontal and is placed at its very center.
It seems to me that could be easier, but i am not sure if it is correct.
Anyway, i found a work around to handle the slant in the images:
1. Run Demetra step by step just until the step called "Geometry" with the "Save step files" ticked.
2. Open all the files with the suffix "G" with BASS software and correct all for slant.
3. Save those corrected files back overwriting the uncorrected ones.
4. Continue running Demetra step by step starting with "Extraction" until the last step, "Crop" (don't click the "RUN" button!).
That is it.
Regarding resolution, i can give you what the theory says:
23μ: R ≈ 1000; Spectral resolution ≈ 5.9 Å; Dispersion ≈ 1.76 Å/pixel
35μ: R ≈ 830; Spectral resolution ≈ 7.0 Å;
That is the theory, the real values are most probably lower. I still don't know yet as i just changed the slit recently.
Yes, i selected an area around a line while trying smile correction. But smile just fixes the curvature of the line, not its slant. I recently knew that Demetra does not correcft for slant. I suppose slant is already taken care of by fixing the slit correctly with the screws, mechanically, and following the procedure stated in the manual. I guess this is the best means, but whenever the slit is changed, the procedure must be done again as the square mirror (the slit) emplacement has some play, it does not sit snuggly. It does not fit exactly in its location. You may try either moving just very slightly the mirror with a small pick until no slant is observed or -better- dismount the spectroscope from the telescope and use those screws to fix it. The manual states that the guider should be used for this correction. I wonder -i did not try it yet- if could it be a good idea to use the calibrating lamp an its spectral lines -using the main camera- to perform this correction by checking the lines verticallity. Also with this procedure it is easy to check if at the acquisition camera's chip the spectrum is horizontal and is placed at its very center.
It seems to me that could be easier, but i am not sure if it is correct.
Anyway, i found a work around to handle the slant in the images:
1. Run Demetra step by step just until the step called "Geometry" with the "Save step files" ticked.
2. Open all the files with the suffix "G" with BASS software and correct all for slant.
3. Save those corrected files back overwriting the uncorrected ones.
4. Continue running Demetra step by step starting with "Extraction" until the last step, "Crop" (don't click the "RUN" button!).
That is it.
Regarding resolution, i can give you what the theory says:
23μ: R ≈ 1000; Spectral resolution ≈ 5.9 Å; Dispersion ≈ 1.76 Å/pixel
35μ: R ≈ 830; Spectral resolution ≈ 7.0 Å;
That is the theory, the real values are most probably lower. I still don't know yet as i just changed the slit recently.
David Cejudo.
Observatorio El gallinero.
El berrueco, Madrid.
Observatorio El gallinero.
El berrueco, Madrid.
-
- Posts: 1952
- Joined: Mon Sep 26, 2011 4:41 pm
- Contact:
Re: Slant with Demetra
That does not sound very useful. (Unless your spectrum is exactly on the radius there will always be a slant component) ISIS smile correction corrects both the curve and the slantDavid Cejudo wrote: But smile just fixes the curvature of the line, not its slant. I recently knew that Demetra does not correcft for slant.
Robin
LHIRES III #29 ATIK314 ALPY 600/200 ATIK428 Star Analyser 100/200 C11 EQ6
http://www.threehillsobservatory.co.uk
http://www.threehillsobservatory.co.uk
-
- Posts: 48
- Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2018 9:01 pm
Re: Slant with Demetra
Here i attach an image of the calibration lamp's spectrum lines at the the step "Geometry." First image shows the lines with a bit of slant, about 5º.
Second image shows the same after hitting the button "Preview". The lines are now obviously more slanted. Smile obviously does not work for slant in Demetra, unless i am doing something wrong.
I forgot to mention that my spectroscope is a LISA!
Second image shows the same after hitting the button "Preview". The lines are now obviously more slanted. Smile obviously does not work for slant in Demetra, unless i am doing something wrong.
I forgot to mention that my spectroscope is a LISA!
David Cejudo.
Observatorio El gallinero.
El berrueco, Madrid.
Observatorio El gallinero.
El berrueco, Madrid.